Rachel Brosnahan soared to the limelight by captivating audiences worldwide with her breakout role as Miriam “Midge” Maisel in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. Since then, she hasn’t looked back and has continued to climb the ladder of success.

Her latest release is the proof of her hard work and dedication. She is currently starring as Lois Lane, a fierce journalist and the romantic interest of Clark Kent, aka Superman, in the new DC movie Superman, which was released on July 11, 2025.

While Brosnahan is moving onto new and bigger things, her portrayal of Midge is still leading netizens to question her religion. And her rising profile doesn’t really help contain that as fans are becoming increasingly curious about her background and cultural heritage.

A common question that often arises is: Is Rachel Brosnahan Jewish?

Rachel Brosnahan Isn’t Jewish by Religion

Despite portraying a Jewish housewife-turned-comedian in The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel, Brosnahan is not Jewish in real life. This fact has often surprised fans who felt her performance as Midge was deeply authentic and rooted in Jewish culture.

So to answer the question “Is Rachel Brosnahan Jewish?” the answer is not Jewish. However, she has previously mentioned having a strong connection to the Jewish community as she was raised in Highland Park, Illinois, a suburb outside of Chicago with its heavily Jewish population.

In her 2015 interview with Chicago Sun Times, she stated, “I spent so many Shabbat dinners with friends. I’ve probably been to 150 bar mitzvahs. A lot of my friends have been on Birthright [trips to Israel]. So this was a cool project to be a part of.”

Additionally, in her 2019 interview with Vulture, the actress said, “Growing up in Highland Park meant having exposure to and a thorough education about Judaism and its culture and community and history — we learned so much about that in school.”

“I’m not sure you have that same level of Jewish education in other parts of the country,” she added. When asked about if she still had sweatpants from the giveaways at Bar Mitzvahs, she revealed she still had many of them and they are really comfortable.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Rachel Brosnahan (@rachelbrosnahan)

Furthermore, it seems like the American actress isn’t much of a religious either.

Rachel Brosnahan’s Ethnicity: A Mixed Heritage

When it comes to ethnicity, Brosnahan is primarily of Irish and English descent, as well as 1/16th French. According to multiple reports, her American father is of Irish and one eighth French descent. The 35-year-old actress’s mother is English.

Her Parents and Family Background

Rachel was born on July 12, 1990, in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and raised in Highland Park, Illinois. Her father, Earl Brosnahan, worked in children’s publishing, while her mother, Carol Brosnahan, managed the home and supported her family.

Besides her parents, Rachel has two siblings: a sister named Lydia Brosnahan and a younger brother, reportedly named Alec Brosnahan. The actress remains close to both her parents and siblings to this day.

Rachel’s parents are also proud of what her daughter has managed to achieve on the grandest stage. However, they weren’t always so confident in their daughter gaining success and were sceptical at first. That said, they were still supportive of her choice.

Rachel Brosnahan during ‘Superman’ press tour in London (Photo: Instagram)

She told Vulture, “To be fair, what parents do want their kids to become actors? [Laughs.] It’s such an uncertain profession, signing up for a lifetime of rejection and uncertainty. No parent wants that for their child.”

“They weren’t the biggest fan of that idea, but they’ve always been really supportive. I don’t think they believed it was real until after the first Golden Globe that I probably wasn’t gonna be moving back into their basement anytime soon.”

She continued, “To be honest, I think the real moment my dad realized I was having success is when his massage therapist said to him that he saw House of Cards. My dad was so surprised that anyone else in the world had seen anything I’d done. [Laughs.] That was the first time he really believed I was doing okay.”

Rachel Brosnahan is related to Fashion Icon Kate Spade

Interestingly, Rachel also shares a familial connection with the world of fashion. She is the niece of the late Kate Spade, the renowned fashion designer and founder of the Kate Spade New York brand. So, Kate is Rachel’s dad’s sister.

A baby Rachel Brosnahan with her aunt Kate Spade (Photo: Instagram)

Rachel has publicly paid tribute to her aunt several times since Spade’s tragic passing in 2018, using her platform to promote mental health awareness. On June 5, 2024, she shared an heartfelt tribute to her late aunt via Instagram.

She wrote, “Sometimes you run out of things to say except I miss you. 6 years without Katy today,” alongside a childhood photo of herself and Spade curled up on a couch to mark the late fashion designer’s sixth death anniversary.

Erin Moriarty is an American actress who was born and raised in New York City. She began acting at the young age of 11 when she played Annie in a community theater production of Annie in 2005. She even skipped college to pursue acting professionally after graduating from high school.

At present, she is best known for her performance as Annie January / Starlight in Amazon Prime Video’s superhero flick The Boys. The critically acclaimed series follows a group of vigilantes attempting to take down a team of superheroes.

Speaking of The Boys, now that season 3 of the show has premiered, the actress is back in the spotlight for her outstanding performance and her changed looks that have surprised her fans. There are rumors that she underwent plastic surgery and looked to have achieved weight loss for the show.

Let’s learn more about her plastic surgery and weight loss rumors.

Erin Moriarty is rumored to have gone through plastic surgery

After the third season of The Boys was released, viewers noticed that Moriarty looked a bit thin and different. Netizens immediately concluded that she had chosen the path of plastic surgery and that her thin looks might be due to weight loss.

One fan even took to their Twitter handle to express their concern about Moriarty’s weight loss, as they wrote, “Erin Moriarty has 100% lost too much weight in season 3 of #TheBoys I am concerned. #starlight.”

Speaking more of the plastic surgery rumors, people began to accuse the actress of having undergone a nose job, shaved down her jawline, botox, and breast enhancements. And while it’s possible that the changes might be due to her aging, it also doesn’t explain such vast and visible changes.

Some have assumed that she has undergone botox to change her appearance subtly. And while some like her new look, some disagree because they think her face was altered far too much by botox and surgery.

Similarly, while some fans doubt that she has had nose surgery and other cosmetic modifications, others say it is simply the result of makeup and lighting. At the same time, many followers blame her transformations on Hollywood pressures and unattainable beauty standards.

Erin Moriarty is making headlines on the internet

The before and after images of Moriarty have been spreading on social media, mainly on Reddit and Twitter. There, people have been discussing her physical change.

For instance, a fan tweeted that the actress looked “weird” since she underwent “needless plastic surgery.” The fan added, “She cant even blink her eyes right.. its [expletive] strange.”

Another chimed, “I can’t believe erin moriarty got surgery to look like how she’s going to naturally look in like 10 years. Are these young female celebrities thinking at all??? [sic]”

Erin Moriarty has not addressed any rumors about her

Moriarty has not made any statements in response to rumors that she has had a face surgery or weight loss. Her new appearance might result from weight loss as she has always been active in fitness, but it doesn’t justify the big changes.

There might be a possibility that she underwent plastic surgery but has been keeping those details away from the public. Besides, Celebrity Post also claims that 75% of experts agree Moriarty has undergone plastic surgery treatments.

Likewise, Dr. Anthony Youn, aka America’s holistic plastic surgeon, had also taken the time to go through Moriarty’s alleged plastic surgery rumors on his YouTube channel. In his video, he said, “One of Erin’s facial characteristics is that her face is relatively round.”

“She has a nice jawline. Her eyebrows are not super harsh. And she has a small nose, maybe with a tiny bump on top of it,” Dr. Youn added. After that, he compared pictures of Moriarty from 2016 and 2022, but it only resulted in conflicting answers.

Upon the comparison, Dr. Youn found that there were some changes, proving the actress might have gone under the knife. But then, he confessed that her eyebrows and jawline look the same in some of her pictures from 2016 as they do now.

And while this doesn’t prove that Moriarty has done any plastic surgery, it also doesn’t conclude that she hasn’t done any plastic surgery.

As Dr. Youn continued, he said, “I do think it’s possible that she may have had a touch of botox recently and that can create some arching of her eyebrows. But, honestly, when I watch her on the show The Boys, I don’t really see any signs of botox at all.”

“Those people saying that she has had some major changes to her jawline, I think that they are just plain wrong,” he added. After that, he mentioned that while the actress hasn’t likely gotten a lip filler, she might have received rhinoplasty.

“It does look like a tiny bump on the top of her nose may have been shaved off. It is possible that her nose may have been narrowed very slightly,” he stated.

Dr. Youn then moved to Moriarty’s cheeks and said, “It does appear that her cheeks may have been a bit lifted or filled out. This can be due to some very subtle injections of filler into her cheeks.”

With that all said, it’s still yet to be proven that Moriarty has undergone plastic surgery or weight loss. Speaking of weight loss, as the actress appeared lean in The Boys season 4, her fans also assumed that she might have an eating disorder and was concerned about her health.

Moriarity has neither confirmed that she suffers from any form of the eating condition. Reports claim she has kept her figure by maintaining a nutritious diet and regularly exercising. It’s said that she favors protein-rich foods such as oats and nutrient-dense fruits for her breakfast.

Erin Moriarty’s career

Moriarty’s acting journey began as a teenager with roles in television series like One Life to Live and Law & Order: Special Victims Unit.

She gained recognition for her performances in films such as The Watch alongside Vince Vaughn, The Kings of Summer, and the sci-fi flick After the Dark.

In 2015, she joined the main cast of Netflix’s Jessica Jones, portraying the character Hope. Beyond her television endeavors, Moriarty impressed audiences with her performances in films like Captain Fantastic and Driven.

In 2017, she secured the role of Annie January / Starlight in Amazon Studios’ The Boys, a role she continued to portray as the series gained popularity with its second season in 2020.

Additionally, Moriarty continued to grace the silver screen, appearing in movies such as Catching Dust and True Haunting in 2023.